Belt Vs Chain Garage Door Openers

Share This Post

How Much Does It Cost To Replace A Garage Door Belt

Belt vs Chain Driven Garage Door Opener

The average cost of replacing a belt drive garage door opener ranges between $275 to $725. However, the prices might scale higher for you, especially if you pay for labor, whereby the services may range between $159 to $379. For accessories like sealants and fasteners, the price ranges between $16 and $19.

The Screw Drive Opener

The screw drive is the most complex of the garage door opener drive mechanisms. The screw drive garage door opener uses a threaded rod that is fixed into a track that runs from the opener to the door. A trolley is attached to the threaded rod and extends an arm to the door, where it is firmly attached. When the door is engaged the motor turns the threaded rod and the trolley moves along the rod either toward the motor or away from it. The arm then raises or lowers the door.

As we stated earlier, belt drive openers and chain drive openers make up more than 95% of all garage door opener sales. The remaining 5% of customers opt for the underdog, the unsung hero of the garage door opener market – screw-drive openers. No, not screwdrivers. Screw-drive openers. Screw-drive openers are an outstanding choice if your door is wider or heavier than average. And, contrary to popular belief, installing them is typically a straightforward affair. So its time to give the screw-drive opener some love – and thats what were going to do below with our six reasons why a screw-drive opener could be the best garage door opener for you.

How Do Chain And Belt Driven Garage Door Openers Work

Whether it is a chain or belt-driven garage door, the purpose of them is the same, to open the garage door smoothly and easily.

Both of the garage doors pull the big metal piece aka trolley up and down on your commands.

The heavy door, without you being pulled down, can be closed and without you opening it, it gets opened with just one press of the button. The difference lies in their tracks, and how they operate.

This guide will help you learn how belt vs chain garage door opens and gets closed, and what are the advantages or disadvantages both have, so that you could decide better which one is the right suit for you.

Recommended Reading: Garage Door Wall Button Replacement

Screw Drive Garage Door Openers

What it is: Screw drive garage door openers are different mechanically than the other two options, as they require a trolley to ride on a threaded-steel rod, which rotates with a motor to move the door. It does not require the same type of pushing and pulling force of traditional belt and chain driven garage door openers.

The advantages: Screw drive openers are simple, and for that reason, preferable for people who want fewer moving parts to maintain. Screw drive units are somewhat sensitive to temperature and are not considered optimal in regions that see drastic shifts in temperature as seasons change. In most cases, they are noisier than belt drive units. Cost-wise, screw drive units tend to be more expensive than belt drive and chain drive openers.

Garage Door Opener Prices

Belt Drive Garage Door Openers Vs. Chain Drive: Which is Better ...

The cost of a garage door opener with installation varies depending on the project complexities and type of garage door. For standard AC garage door openers, consumers should expect to pay around $500 . DC openers, heavy duty openers, and openers with advanced features can cost up to $3000 , although the average cost is around $1000.

Big home improvement retailers may offer low-cost openers and installations however, they sell retail light duty brands like Chamberlain and Genie. These openers are more suitable for light garage doors, they are built with light duty parts and hardware, and might not pass the test of time. Additionally, big retailers dont employ in-house installers, they outsource their installation projects to a third-party hiring company who dispatch unlicensed individuals and takes a percentage of each sale. Typically, these temporary workers will be on the lookout for possible upselling opportunists since their pay is not adequate to cover their expenses and rising cost of inflation.

You May Like: Why Is My Garage Door Opening On Its Own

Convenience: Chain Vs Belt

One concern is convenience, which depends on how easily the opener can be installed and maintained. Both of these openers can last for over ten years, but they require different upkeep.

Chain drives need to be lubricated on a regular basis, and they may need to be adjusted once in a while. A belt drive does not require any lubrication or adjustments except for the initial gear lubrication.

Therefore when it comes to convenience, a belt drive is the easiest to handle as there isnt much to owning one. Simply make sure that its working correctly when you operate it and go on about your day.

How Chain And Belt Garage Door Openers Work

The way each of these systems work is pretty much exactly how it sounds. A chain drive uses a long metal chain to open and close a garage door, while a belt drive uses a rubber belt. The function is the same, but the tools to do it are different.

A chain drive garage door opener works by using a chain running assembly unit to open and close the garage. The chain running assembly consists of an interconnection of gears, metal parts and tension springs that work together to lift the garage door. A belt drive garage door operates by moving a rubber belt to slide the trolley open and closed.

Lets take a closer look at these two types of garage openers, their advantages, disadvantages and characteristics that may help you decide which is right for you chain or belt garage door openers.

Recommended Reading: Griot’s Garage 6 Random Orbital Polisher Kit

The Benefits Of A Belt Drive Garage Door Opener

  • Quite: There may be nothing more irritating than an insanely loud garage door opener. When it comes to belt drive openers, sound is seldom an issue. Belt drive might be the finest option if a whisper-quiet door is on your essential list.
  • Strong: Once upon a time, belt drive garage door openers were only known to do easy work. Technology has actually significantly improved the performance of these belts, making them strong sufficient for nearly every home garage door application.
  • Replacement: Most garage door specialists agree that setting up a new belt is noticeably easier than changing out a chain.
  • Popular: Belt drives have ended up being popular to the factor that their components are commonly readily available. This style of garage door opener can be purchased at practically any type of house enhancement seller. Your neighborhood garage door company will certainly have a huge selection of them.
  • Upkeep: Maintenance is very easy, as belts do not need the lubrication a chain drive opener does.

Jack Shaft Openers Glossy And Verbose

Quiet Garage Door Opener – Chain vs Belt

The jack shaft is the modern door technology that you can get today. It offers some very unique and attractive features that give it the edge over its competitors. First and foremost, the stub shaft comes with a stand by system that allows it to function during a power failure.

These are very popular in states that are vulnerable to power outages due to tornadoes or other natural disasters. The second most important feature of the jack shaft is that it can be mounted on a wall plate instead of the ceiling.

Also Read: How to Dispose of Old Gas Oil Mix

Also Check: Roll Up Garage Door Installation

Belt Vs Chain Drive Garage Door Openers Which Is Better

Both belt driven-openers and chain drive garage door operating systems stand as one of the most popular types of garage door openers. They have both dominated many homes because of the convenience they deliver. However, there are variations between these two systems.

These differences lay a base for determining suitability. For instance, if you have a heavy garage door, chain drive systems will be more suitable since they have more power.

I will shed light on these variations with respect to scopes such as

When Should You Use A Belt Drive Instead Of A Chain

Belt drive garage openers can be used for one-car garages and lightweight doors. Theyre ideal when you want to cut down on noise and when you want minimal maintenance. Some people dont want to be bothered by the frequent maintenance that comes with a chain drive opener.

Also, some belt drive models are wired with Wi-Fi capabilities, so if this is something you feel that youll benefit from, you should use a belt drive instead of a chain drive.

Recommended Reading: Insulated Garage Door With Windows

Pros And Cons Of Chain Drive Garage Door Opener


  • Strong and Durable: Chain drives are more reliable, and proper maintenance will make it last longer. They are reliable throughout the year.
  • Available: You can find chain drive in home improvement stores and at various hardware centers. It is also available at any local garage door installation company and its affiliates.
  • Affordable: Compared to belt drive, chain drives more affordable.


  • Smooth Operation: due to the metal parts that make up chain drives, they usually shake and bounce when used. They are slower in lifting the door and a few seconds behind when compared to belt drive opener.
  • Maintenance: Since they are made of metal gears and other iron components, chain drive requires regular lubrication. If you dont maintain it, this will cause the iron to rust and stiffen, and eventually, the machine will stop working.

Contact Liberty Door And Awning For Belt And Chain Drive Openers


Liberty Door and Awning has been the largest Clopay® Garage Door Dealer in the state of New Jersey for over 20 years. Serving Atlantic, Middlesex, Mercer, Monmouth and Ocean Counties, we take pride in our talent for garage door and awning installation and repair. For more information about our garage door selection or to have us install one of our openers, be sure to contact Liberty Door and Awning today.

Read Also: Garage Door Repair Hillsboro Oregon

The Best Garage Door Opener

Although all makes and models of garage door openers accomplish the same goal, they are built differently and offer different benefits. Consumers may want to make sure that the opener they buy has all the right features and torque output.

Garage door openers that are powered by DC motors are more expensive to manufacture, more efficient, quiet and can be used with a backup power source such as batteries in case of a power surge. If you live in California, Senate Bill 969 illegalized AC garage door openers, requiring homeowners, property owners, homebuilders and garage door repair companies to install DC garage door openers only.

Garage door openers that are powered by AC motors are more affordable, and considered to be more powerful than DC openers because they can utilize higher electric current to produce more torque and lifting power. However, they vibrate, produce more noise and cannot be used with a designated backup battery power supply.

Keep reading:

Pros And Cons Of Belt Garage Door Opener


  • Easy to install: It is easy to carry out a belt garage door opener repair or replacement when it is worn out or broken.
  • Readily Available: You can easily get a belt drives at many home improvement stores. It is also available for purchase at garage door companies.


  • Performance Rate: Under perfect conditions, belt drives work great, but it cannot withstand extreme heat or high humidity.
  • Duration: belt drives are made from rubber, so they do not last long like chain drives. The rubber belt needs regular replacement to keep them operating smoothly.
  • Purchase Price: Belt drives are more expensive than chain drives, and not many people can afford the cost. The upside to this is that they come with a better warranty than a chain door opener.

Read Also: Small Homes With Rv Garages

A Comprehensive Comparison Of Chain And Belt Openers

Each kind of garage door opener has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. The option isnt black and white, as it is with most things in life. There are multiple factors to consider before making a final decision.

We will examine four of the most significant characteristics of garage door openers in this section:

However, keep in mind that you should consider other factors such as your homes location and garage size before making a final selection.

Which Is More Efficient: Belt Or Chain

Chain Driven vs Belt Driven Garage Door Openers

Chain drive openers are more efficient. They can provide higher amounts of strength for much less money and thus are frequently selected for larger doors and deserted areas. In deserted areas, its better to have a steel carriage for extra protection, which is something that chain drives have no issue lifting.

A chain would outlast a belt with adequate maintenance, albeit the regular use makes a difference. Chain drive openers, like belt drive openers, are available with 1/2 hp to 3/4 hp motors, offering enough power for all of our household garage door models.

Chains have better tensile strength and lifting capability than belts and are commonly utilized on home garage door openers. In some applications, they may also endure longer. The chain is attached with an adjustable clip and powered by a sprocket on top of the motor, similar to how belts are installed.

Recommended Reading: Garage Door Repair Knoxville Tn

Chain Garage Door Opener

  • Strong, durable, and more reliable .
  • Widely available at home improvement stores, hardware stores and garage door installation companies.
  • More affordable compared to belt drives.
  • Gives you more options for garage door types.


  • Noisier than a belt drive.
  • Does require routine maintenance.
  • Easier to maintain because it doesnt require lubrication.
  • Slightly faster than chain drive garage door openers.


  • Not as durable as a chain drive so may need replacing.

Belt Vs Chain Garage: Which Is Right For You And Your Home

At Precision Door Delaware, we hope that this guide on belt vs. chain garage door openers helped you get a sense of what these respective drives offer to your garage door experience. While youre aware of the pros and cons of both, you may need more details to decide which is right for your garage door. When its time to get closer to making your decision, you can always contact us to learn more or get a free estimate on the installation!

Our team at Precision Door Delaware is proud to help and serve homeowners inn Delaware and North Maryland with their garage door needs!

You May Like: Retractable Garage Screen Door Kits

Strength Of The Chain Vs Belt Drives

It is evident that the two drives function the same way, but a chain drive is more durable than a belt drive. Unlike belt drives, chain drives can lift and move more massive doors, which is why many prefer it. Chain drives are best for steel carriages and not suitable for less heavy door models.

Chain drives can handle two-car and three-car garages without difficulty. But belt drive cannot handle heavy objects beyond the recommended weight such as heavy wooden doors or two or three-car garages.

For one carriage door, a belt drive can get the work done without troubles. However, due to technology improvement, there are belt drives that can carry any size of door with ease.

Chain Vs Belt Drive Garage Door Openers Which Is Right For You

pros and cons of belt drive vs chain drive garage door openers

Among all the factors to consider when shopping for garage door openers, the type of drive mechanism is probably not something you hear about very often. Yet, when using the opener, you may hear a difference in the sound of belt drive units because they are generally quieter than chain drive openers, though that isnt the only operating feature to consider.

We should point out that there are many offsetting advantages of chain drive openers, so please dont count them out. Still, if you have an attached garage and especially if you have bedrooms located above the garage, the sound rating of the garage door opener may indeed be at or near the top of your selection criteria.

Belt Drive Openers

Todays high-strength drive belts will handle the weight loads of most single or double residential garage doors. This type of drive system runs along the rail and wraps around a sprocket located on the top of the opener. The belt ends are joined at the drive trolley with a threaded clip that can be adjusted to keep the belt tight. Your Raynor Dealer may recommend this type of opener for all except the heaviest doors such as composite overlay or all-wood doors.

Chain Drive Openers

Other Considerations

QUICK COMPARIS0N Raynor Garage Door Openers

Ready For A New Opener?

Don’t Miss: 12 Foot Wide Garage Door Prices

Affordability: Chain Vs Belt Drives

The chain drive is more affordable and has a history of useful functionality and availability in the market. It is common to see many garage owners using chain drive to operate their garage doors. However, the chain drive wears faster due to the continuous friction of the movement of metal parts.

The belt drive is accessible but is on the high side when it comes to price. But in the long run, it seems to be a wise choice since it is more durable than a chain drive. The reason for this long shelf life is that, unlike a chain drive that moves the door with its chain, belt drive operates with the help of a trolley.

Related Posts